| Journal of Neurosurgical Anesthesiology,
Vol. 9, No. 4, pp. 296-307 © 1997 Lippincott-Raven Publishers,
Philadelphia
Special Report
CELEBRATING
SILVER:
The Genesis
of a Neuroanesthesiology Society
NAS --+ SNANSC
--+ SNACC
Maurice S.
Albin, M.D., M.Sc (Anes.)
Professor of Anesthesiology and Neurosurgery,
Department of Anesthesiology,
University of Texas Health Center, San
Antonio, Texas
Address correspondence
and reprint requests to Dr. Maurice S. Albin at the University
of Texas Health Center, Department of Anesthesiology, 7703
Floyd Curl Drive, San Antonio. TX, 78284, U.S.A.
Key Words:
History: Neuroanesthesiology-Neurosurgical Anesthesiology
-Neuroanesthesiology-Neurosurgical Anesthesiology; NSA: Neuroanesthesia
Society; SNANSC: Society of Neurosurgical Anesthesia and Neurological
Supportive Care; SNACC: Society of Neurosurgical Anesthesia
and Critical Care
The decade of the sixties was seminal
for the development of neuroanesthesiology as a definitive
subspecialty. During those years, standardization of techniques
for measurement of CBF, CMRO2, ICP and neurochemical moieties
were introduced. The physiologic basis of cerebrovascular
dynamics was being established and instrumentation design
was spurred by developments in electronics and engineering.
Of equal importance, research groups of anesthesiologists
and neurosurgeons were coalescing in Europe and North America
to examine the effects of anesthetics on cerebral blood flow
and metabolism, on cerebrovascular responses of the traumatized
brain, and the dynamics of intracranial hypertension-to name
but a three areas of investigation. This multidisciplinary
approach was spurred as neurosurgeons and anesthesiologists
came to realize that they had common ground in their need
to clarify essential pathophysiologic problems relating to
patient care. Along with those advances, new findings in neurochemistry
and the beginning of important developments in the (then)
new subspecialty of neuroradiology increased the background
of intellectual ferment that heralded great strides in the
decade of the seventies.
This is not to say that significant advances
or discoveries had not been made prior to the sixties. We
are forever indebted to the works of Amussat, Sherrington,
Bernard, Horsley, Macewen, Halsted, Cushing, Kety, and Schmidt,
among many others. A fine review of the background to the
history of neuroanesthesiology can be found in a recent work
by Frost (1).
The
academic purview of neuroanesthesiology was promoted in 1964
by publication of the first neuroanesthesiology textbook written
in English by Professor Andrew R. Hunter from Manchester (Fig.
1) (2). This was followed in 1966 by the first Canadian book
in neuroanesthesiology edited by R.G.B. Gilbert (then Chair
of the Department of Anaesthetics at McGill University and
Director of Anaesthesia at the Montreal Neurological Institute)
together with Fred Brindle and Anibal Galindo (3). During
this time period (1965), Dr. Allan Brown of Edinburgh and
Professor Hunter founded the Neuroanesthesia Traveling Club
of Great Britain and Ireland, an organization dedicated to
furthering the development of the neuroanesthesiology as a
recognized subspecialty. Also of interest was the formation
in 1961 of a North American working group called the Commission
on Neuroanesthesia, sponsored by the World Federation of Neurology,
and initially composed of Howard Terry (Mayo Clinic), Jack
Michenfelder (Mayo Clinic), Maurice Albin (Case-Western Reserve),
and chaired by R.G.B. Gilbert (McGill). A rapid development
of knowledge relating to neuroanesthesiology from centers
in Philadelphia, Glasgow, Rochester, Richmond, San Francisco,
London, New York, Cleveland, and Montreal was soon to follow.
FIG.
1. Professor Andrew R. Hunter, pioneering neuroanesthesiologist,
author of the first book on neuroanesthesia in English (1964),
and cofounder of the Neuroanesthesia Traveling Club of Great
Britain and Ireland in 1965.
FIG.2.
Maurice S. Albin, M.D., M.Sc. (Anes), one of the original
organizers (1972) and founders (1973) of NAS and its 2nd President.
FIG.3.
Thomas W. Langfitt, M.D. The neurosurgical "Guru"
of North American Neuroanesthesia-both founder and organizer
of NAS in 1972 and 1973.
In May
of 1972, Thomas W. Langfitt (Professor and Chief of the Division
of Neurosurgery at the University of Pennsylvania) was a visiting
Professor at the University of Pittsburgh. During that sojourn
he and I had many conversations concerning the need to form
some type of organization for neuroanesthesiologists working
closely with neurosurgeons (Figs. 2,3). On returning to Philadelphia,
he spoke with James E. Harp (Department of Anesthesiology,
University of Pennsylvania-Fig. 4) about our conversations
and this resulted in a letter of June 6, 1972, and my reply
of June 14, 1972 (Fig.5,6). Doctor Harp and I remained in
contact during the remainder of 1972, and we collated a mailing
list of individuals in the United States and Canada who might
be interested in joining such a group. We decided that the
perfect location for a preliminary meeting would be Philadelphia,
in conjunction with the Sixth International Cerebral Blood
Flow Symposium. We were also pleased to have Harvey Shapiro
(University of Pennsylvania) join our neuroanesthesiology
crusade (Fig. 7). The Philadelphia CBF venue was very important
since many interested anesthesiologists and neurosurgeons
were in attendance. A specimen letter from our committee,
announcing the meeting and the suggested goals, can be seen
in Figs. 8 and 9.
FIG.4. James Harp, M.D., one of the original
organizers (1972) and founder of NAS (1973).
FIG. 5. Letter from James Harp to Maurice
Albin concerning formation of a neuroanesthesia group.
Hosted
by Drs. Thomas Langfitt and Harry Wollman (Department of Anesthesiology,
University of Pennsylvania - Fig. 10), the first organizational
meeting took place on June 15, 1973, at the Marriott Motor
Hotel in Philadelphia. It was attended by 36 anesthesiologists
and 4 neurosurgeons (Fig. 11). We named our group the Neurosurgical
Anesthesia Society (NAS); a brief portion of the bylaws can
be seen in Figure 12. One important outcome of this meeting
was Dr. Langfitt's willingness to include NAS in the programs
of the Harvey Cushing Society (subsequently named the American
Association of Neurologic Surgeons).
FIG. 6. Letter
from Maurice Albin to James Harp regarding plans for
a neuroanesthesia group.
FIG. 7. Harvey Shapiro, M.D., one of the
original founders of SNA, first Secretary and 4th President
of SNANSC.
FIG. 8. Specimen letter concerning the
preliminary organizational meeting of the Neurosurgical Anesthesia
Society. This letter was sent out to anesthesiologists and
neurosurgeons thought to he interested in the organization.
FIG. 9. The suggested goals for the proposed
Neuroanesthesia Society.
FIG. 10. Harry Wollman, M.D., one of the
founding members of NAS and a host of the 1973 organizational
meeting in Philadelphia.
MEMBERS OF THE
'NEUROSURGICAL ANESTHESIA SOCIETY'
(Jun. 15, 1973)
M. Albin, M.D. Pittsburgh, PA
S. C. Alexander, M.D. Madison, WI
D. P. Becker, M.D. Richmond, VA
R. Bergland, K.D. He r hey, PA
V.L. Brechner, M.D. Los Angels, CA
G.F, Brindle, M.W. Sherbrooke, PQ
E.A. Brunner, M.D. Chicago, IL
R.C. Carroll, M.D. Pittsburgh, PA
J.G. Frazer, M.D. Cleveland, ON
A. Galindo, M.D. Seattle, WA
R.G.B. Gilbert, M.D. Montreal, CANADA
T.S. Gilbert, M.D. Durham, N.C.
A.J. Gissen. M.D. Boston, MA
G.A, Gronert, M.D. Rochester, MI
J. Harp M.D. Philadelphia
M. Helrich, M.D. Baltimore, HD
E.M. Kenwell. M.D. Philadelphia. PA
L.K. Kitathata, M.D., Ph.D. New Haven, CT
H.J. Khambatta, M.D. New York, N.Y.
V.E. Lamb K.D. Chicago, IL.
T.W. Langfitt, M.D. Philadelphia. PA
C.P. Larson, Jr., M.D. San Francisco, CA
J.D. Levitt, M.D. Philadelphia, PA
Brian Marshall, M.D. Toronto, ON
K.J. Matjasko, M.D. Baltimore, NO
J.H. Messick, Jr. M.D. Rochester, MI
J.D. Michenfelder, M.D. Rochester. MI
L.R. Orkin, M.D. Mew York , NY
A. Schettini, M.D. Gainesville, FL
M.H. Shapiro, M.D. Philadelphia, PA.
H.C. Slocum, M.D. Galveston, TX
A.L. Smith, M.D. San Francisco, CA
R. Smith, M.D. San Diego, CA
M. Sokol, M.D. Iowa City, IA
J. Tinker, M.D. Ft. Campbell, KY
D. Trop, M.D. Montreal, PQ
J.W. Wads, M.D. Winnipeg, KB
R.J. White, M.D. Cleveland, OH
H. Wollman, M.D. Philadelphia. PA
A. Yeakel, M.D. Hershey. PA
FIG. 11. Charter members of the Neurosurgical
Anesthesia Society at its meeting on June 15, 1973. Four neurosurgeons
were present including Becker, Bergland, Langfitt, and White
FIG. 12. A portion of the articles of
organization and by-laws of the Neurosurgical Anesthesia Society.
FIG. 13. Part of the program at the 1975
AANS indicating two of the SNANSC contributions.
FIG. 14. Specimen of letter sent to all
neurosurgical and anesthesia programs in the United States
and Canada announcing its meeting in San Francisco on October
7, 1973.
This
allowed our members to interact with neurosurgeons through
panel discussions and workshops and through the presentation
of papers on subjects related to our two specialties. An example
of the participation of our membership is shown in the flyer
for the 1975 meeting (Fig. 13).
After
the first organizational meeting on June 15, 1973, an ad hoc
committee of members Shapiro, Harp, and I sent a letter to
all program directors in anesthesiology and neurological surgery
concerning the formation of the Neurosurgical Anesthesia Society.
The letter emphasized that this new group would be multidisciplinary,
with an open membership (Fig. 14). It also mentioned that
the first organized meeting of the Society would take place
on October 7, 1973, in San Francisco, since the ASA was to
meet there that year. In addition to Drs. Harp, Shapiro, and
1, the ad hoc committee also included Drs. Alan Smith (San
Francisco), Stephen Wyte (Denver), Brian Marshall (Toronto),
John Wade (Winnipeg), and Anibal Galindo (Seattle). We contacted
all individuals whom we thought would have interest in NAS
and invited them to attend. Our San Francisco contact at that
time was Alan L. Smith (UCSF), who handled local arrangements
as well as the dinner (which was an outrageous sum of $7.50
per head!) (Fig. 15). Annual dues at the 1973 meeting were
$15.00 and this fee remained in effect for several years.
FIG. 15. Letter from Harvey Shapiro (acting
secretary) concerning the members of the NAS, annual dues
form, and mailing list.
FIG. 16. John Mitchenfelder, M.D., 1st
President and a founder (1973) of NAS.
The meeting
was important because it implemented a definitive organizational
structure. The Neurosurgical Anesthesia Society was changed
to the Society of Neurosurgical Anesthesia and Neurological
Supportive Care (SNANSC) since it was felt that the new name
would be more open, allowing for more disciplines to enter
the organization and the name also more clearly defined our
group aims. At this meeting, which was attended by more than
45 professionals, a constitution and bylaws were adopted and
officers were elected. The officers were John D. Michenfelder,
(Rochester, Minnesota) President (Fig. 16); Maurice Albin
(Pittsburgh), President-Elect; Brian Marshall (Toronto), Vice-President;
and Harvey Shapiro (Philadelphia) Secretary-Treasurer. A program
committee was chosen for the Annual Conference and Meeting
to take place on October 11, 1974, in Washington, D.C., prior
to the annual ASA meeting. The program (Fig. 17) was enhanced
by active participation of neurosurgeons-a hallmark of our
organization since its inception. In fact, six of our Presidents
have been neurosurgeons. I know of no other society in anesthesiology
with this type of collaborative effort taking place on both
sides of the table. The meeting fee (including luncheon and
the educational materials) cost $15 for members and $20 for
non-members. This successful meeting was attended by 150 registrants.
Of particular note was the effort of Aaron Gissen (Boston)
who developed protocols/questionnaires concerning anesthesia-
neurosurgical problems and practices (Fig. 19).
Figure 17. Program of the first annual
conference in 1974 at Washington D.C.
Figure 18. A portion of the 1974 fall
newsletter
The programs
of the 1975 (Chicago) and 1976 (San Francisco) meetings (Figs.
20,21) illustrate the development, inclusiveness and intellectual
depth of our undertaking. A review of the topics in both programs
demonstrates the wide variety of our members' concerns relating
to clinical, basic science, and educational objectives. The
international aspect of our interests was evidenced by the
number of European participants. A sense of déja vu
is elicited by the title of the first topic for discussion
at the 1976 meeting- "Pharmacologic Protection against
Brain Injury." Starting, with the 1974 meeting, the scientific
programs consisted of free papers covering experimental studies
or clinical protocols. Eleven papers were presented at our
1976 meeting (Fig. 22). 1975-76 dues were $15.00, meeting
registration was $25.00 for members, $30.00 for non-members,
and the dinner cost had doubled to $15.00.
Neuroanesthesiology
was formally recognized by the ASA as a subspecialty in 1976
while James E. Cottrell served as Chair of the ASA Subspecialty
Committee. By the end of 1976, organizational aspects had
stabilized and we could boast more than 160 members from institutions
in the United States, Canada, and Mexico. Our membership now
included anesthesiologists, neurosurgeons, neurologists, engineers,
and neuroscientists. We had established a newsletter (Fig.
23), and our meetings were being reported in Anesthesiology.
Anesthesiologists and neurosurgeons throughout the United
States and Canada interested in neuroanesthesiology had been
contacted, and SNANSC participated actively in panels and
presentations at the American Association of Neurological
Surgeons (Fig. 24). The educational component of our Society
expanded in 1974 with guidelines developed by Aaron Gissen
for the management of induced hypotension, carotid endarterectomy,
and air embolism. Concomitantly, in 1975, James E. Cottrell
was developing questions for a survey of the number and types
of cases carried out by anesthesiology residents during their
first two years of clinical training as well as the nature
of neuroanesthesiology and surgical practices. Preliminary
information in this area was presented during our 1976 meeting
by Drs. Cottrell (New York), Harp (Philadelphia) and Jannetta
(Pittsburgh). An educational subcommittee was organized to
develop a bibliography pertinent to our research, clinical,
and educational practices. We were in constant contact with
our European colleagues and plans were made to meet with our
British counterparts (Fig. 25). Those plans came to fruition
during a joint meeting in Williamsburg, Virginia in 1979.
A combined meeting was held a few years later in London, England.
We had also developed a relationship with ASA vis-a-vis the
role of subspecialty groups within the organization; sponsored
and arranged the neuroanesthesia breakfast panel at the ASA;
and achieved representation on the ASA Refresher Course committee.
FIG. 19. Letter from Aaron Gissen concerning
evaluation of management of induced hypotension, carotid endarterectomy,
and air embolism.
FIG 20. The 1975 program.
FIG. 21. The program for the October,
1976, meeting. The subject of brain protection and the problem
of education in neuroanesthesia were highlighted.
The first U.S.A.
textbook in neuroanesthesiology (4), now in its third edition
(5), was published in 1980. By 1982 (our tenth anniversary),
we had experienced considerable growth in membership and the
participants obviously enjoyed the meeting (Fig. 26). This
celebration was shadowed by the death of Brian M. Marshall
(Toronto), one of our founding members and President from
1976-77; we dedicated this meeting in his memory. At our 1986
meeting, SNANSC became the Society of Neurosurgical Anesthesia
and Critical Care (SNACC) in order to recognize the importance
of critical care medicine to patients with severe neurological
dysfunction.
FIG. 22. The eleven free papers presented
at the 1976 scientific session.
FIG. 23. The 1976 summer newsletter. Note
in the fifth paragraph that SNANSC sponsored a breakfast panel
at the ASA which continues to this day.
FIG. 24. A portion of the 1976 SNANSC
spring newsletter indicating our participation at the AANS
meeting.
1989 saw the launch of the Journal of
Neurosurgical Anesthesiology (JNA) with James E. Cottrell
serving as Editor, John Hartung as Associate Editor, and Roberta
Halporn as JNA's Editorial Office Manager (Figs. 27-29). This
journal has since become the voice of SNACC, as well as that
of the Association de Neuro-Anésthesiologie et Réanimation
de langue Francaise, the Wissenschaflicher Arbeitskreis Neuroanästhesie
der Deutschen Gesellschaft für Anästhesiologie und
Intensivemedizin, the Neuroanesthesia Society of Great Britain
and Ireland, and the Arbeitsgemeinschaft Deutschsprachiger
Neuroanäthesisten und Neurointensivmediziner.
FIG.25. Letter to Gordon McDowall, an
officer of the Neuroanesthesia Traveling Club of Great Britain
and Ireland.
FIG. 26. A portion of the SNANSC newsletter
of 1982, commenting on our 10th anniversary.
FIG. 27. James Cottrell, M.D., Founding
Editor of Journal of Neurosurgical Anesthesiology in 1989
and 8th President of SNANSC.
Our twentieth anniversary
meeting was celebrated in New Orleans in 1992. It had historical
overtones as John D. (Jack) Michenfelder gave the Janssen
Distinguished Lecture on "The Past, Present, and Future
of Research in Neuroanesthesia." Jack is a founding member
of NAS, our society's first President, a former editor of
Anesthesiology and an eminent scholar, scientist, and neuroanesthesiology
educator. Another extraordinary event took place that evening
when Thomas W. Langfitt spoke about changes taking place in
the American health care system. Dr. Langfitt is the neurosurgical
founder and a charter member of our Society. The work on head
injury and intracranial hypertension carried out in his laboratories
remains outstanding in its originality and scope, and he trained
many physicians who subsequently occupied, or still occupy,
Chairs in Neurosurgery departments.
FIG. 28. John Hartung, Ph.D., Associate
Editor of the Journal of Neurosurgical Anesthesiology since
its inception.
FIG. 29. Table of Contents of Vol 1, No.
1, of JNA
FIG. 30. Listing of the Presidents of
NAS, SNANSC, and SNACC
FIG. 31. M. Jane Matjasko, M.D., founding
member of the NAS and the 10th President.
In 1972, only six
anesthesiology training programs in the United States and
Canada had a dedicated neuroanesthesiology division or section
for residency teaching and fellowship training. As of 1989,
there were sixty-four neuroanesthesia training programs in
the United States and Canada. Looking back at the past 25
years, I cannot help but be impressed by the progress we have
made both in clinical and investigative neuroanesthesiology,
by the ability of our subspecialty to attract many of the
best and brightest in our specialty, and by the capacity of
our present leaders to point the way to the future. We have
always been fortunate to have superb leadership, as scanning
the list of past Society Presidents indicates (Fig. 30). We
were also cognizant of the capabilities of our female members
long before the term, "glass ceiling," was coined,
with Jane Matjasko, Philippa Newfield, Elizabeth Frost, Judith
Donegan, and Betty Grundy (Figs. 31-34) each making substantial
contributions.
FIG. 32. Elizabeth A.M. Frost, M.D., early
contributor to SNANSC
FIG. 33. Phillipa Newfield, M.D., 14th
President of SNANSC.
FIG. 34. Elizabeth Grundy, M.D., early
contributor to SNANSC.
Dozens of individuals
have been responsible for the health and vigor of our neuroanesthesiology
organization and space limitations do not allow for a more
in-depth narration of their contributions. These individuals
helped in various ways such as organizing meetings, serving
on committees, reviewing the literature concerning neuroanesthesiology,
judging abstracts, and performing the many thankless tasks
that make our organization function-one can only salute them
and thank them for their efforts.
We look forward
to celebrating our thirtieth anniversary in 2002!
References
1. Frost EAM. History of neuroanesthesia.
In: Albin, MS ed. Textbook of Neuroanesthesia with Neurosurgical
and Neuroscience Perspectives. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1997:1-20.
2. Hunter AF. Neurosurgical Anesthesia.
Philadelphia: F.A. Davis Co., 1964.
3. Gilbert RGB, Brindle GF, Galindo A.
Anesthesia for Neurosurgery. London: J & A Churchill Co,
1966.
4. Cottrell JE, Turndorf H. Anesthesia
and Neurosurgery. St. Louis: Mosby-Yearbook Inc, 1980.
5. Cottrell JE, Smith DS. Anesthesia and
Neurosurgery. St. Louis: Mosby Yearbook, Inc, 1994.
|